| Blacks versus browns
Ruben Navarrette
UNION-TRIBUNE
From:
http://www.signonsandiego.com/news/op-ed/navarrette/20060201-9999-lz1e1navarr.html
February 1, 2006
In college, my African-American
friends and I used to call it “the black-brown thing.” It's the
uneasy tension – and occasional conflict – between the nation's
largest minority and the group that formerly held the title.
In the 1990s, the phenomenon was most prevalent in major cities
such as Los Angeles, New York, Chicago and Miami – large urban
centers where significant numbers of African-Americans and Latinos
lived side by side.
Today, ground zero is New Orleans, where a lot of
African-Americans are no longer sure they want to live and where a
lot more Latinos have gone to find work.
The fact that there is a new spice in the gumbo hasn't gotten by
the Rev. Jesse Jackson. Since Hurricane Katrina struck, the civil
rights leader has worried about the city's changing demographics in
a way that brings to mind how whites used to worry about
African-Americans moving into cities before many of those whites
took flight to the suburbs.
During a recent appearance on CNN's “Lou Dobbs Tonight,” Jackson
again complained that, as New Orleans is being rebuilt, “outside
workers” are displacing natives of the city. (Translation: Latino
immigrants are taking jobs that might otherwise go to
African-Americans.)
Jackson was careful not to frame the issue in terms of illegal
immigration despite prodding from Dobbs, who has spun hysteria over
foreigners into ratings gold. What Jackson did seem eager to talk
about, however, was what was happening now that many Latinos have
moved to New Orleans.
At least he's honest. It's the one thing that is often at the
root of concern over illegal immigration – the fact that it changes
the landscape of cities, towns and neighborhoods in ways that many
Americans often find disconcerting. Jackson noted that while New
Orleans was 3 percent Hispanic before Katrina, it is now 20 percent
Hispanic.
Jackson said that he plans a march and a protest on April 1 to
demand that native workers be given priority over foreign ones in
the rebuilding of New Orleans.
A perfect choice – April Fool's Day for a foolish idea. The jobs
are there for the taking, and many of them pay well. Yet polls show
that large numbers of the African-Americans who fled New Orleans
have no desire to return. Someone has to do those jobs, and often
that “someone” is a Latino immigrant who doesn't mind roughing it in
a demolished city that still lacks many basic services. Jackson's
impractical solution is for companies to provide affordable housing
for workers.
The protesters should scrap the march and have a parade. For
grand marshal, I nominate New Orleans Mayor Ray Nagin, who not long
ago complained that Mexican workers were “overrunning” New Orleans.
Black leaders are naturally going to protect their power
base and preserve their influence. But as the rhetoric
filters down to the workers themselves, African-Americans
might actually buy into this idea that they're being crowded
out by Latinos. In fact, it may have already happened.
According to a recent article in The Wall Street Journal, there
is a new wave of race-discrimination cases showing up at the U.S.
Equal Employment Opportunity Commission. The cases involve
African-Americans who feel they've been passed over for Latinos.
What's more, the agency has actually found for the plaintiffs in a
few of these cases and secured settlements from companies on their
behalf.
Even so, I still have a tough time believing that
African-Americans are being held back by Latinos. And I have an even
tougher time drawing comparisons to what happened in the 1950s and
'60s when white employers – believing that African-Americans were
inferior – rejected black job applicants in favor of other whites.
Is the argument that the employers of today consider
African-Americans inferior to Latinos?
I prefer the argument made by an African-American friend with
whom I once hosted a radio show in Los Angeles. Whenever black
callers complained about Mexican immigrants taking jobs, he would
jump on their case. “You have to aim higher than that,” he'd tell
them. Instead of fighting with Latinos for the bad jobs, he would
say, you should compete with whites for the good ones.
He was absolutely right. Whether you're black, white, brown or
purple, life is about competition and accumulating the skills to
withstand it. If you find yourself in a situation where you're
afraid of being forced out of a job, or beaten out for a job, by a
low-skilled, non-English speaking immigrant with nothing more than a
sixth-grade education, then you have bigger worries than where your
next paycheck is coming from. |