REVIEW &
OUTLOOK
Help Wanted
Immigration reform is good policy--and
good politics.
Wednesday, October 16, 2002 12:01 a.m.
Now that House Minority Leader Dick
Gephardt has introduced legislation that would allow millions of undocumented
aliens in the U.S. to earn legal status, maybe the White House will stop
ducking the issue and reply with its own initiative.
Last week, Mr. Gephardt told a crowd of enthusiastic Hispanics that to pass
his bill, "we need a Democratic majority" in Congress. Actually, all we really
need is for the Bush Administration to revive its pre-9/11 plans for
addressing the Rio Grande influx. Aside from helping to secure Latino votes,
which explains Mr. Gephardt's timing, a sensible policy on Mexican immigration
would both enhance border security and satisfy pressing needs of the U.S.
economy.
An estimated three million undocumented Mexicans already live and work in
the U.S. Contrary to what critics say about "stealing" American jobs, the
truth is that they fill mostly menial slots that Americans would sooner spurn.
They are field hands, nannies, landscapers, custodians, busboys, dishwashers,
chambermaids and construction workers. According to the Labor Department, by
2010 there will be more than 20 million job openings for people with minimal
education. Mexican workers aren't a problem; they're a solution.
The American Immigration Law Foundation reports that the U.S. economy
absorbed three million Mexican workers during the 1990s, yet unemployment
still fell to 3.9% in 2000 from 6.3% in 1990. A decade ago California, Texas
and Illinois accounted for 85% of these individuals. Today that number has
dropped to 68% as the demand for immigrant labor has spread to places like
Tennessee, Alabama, Missouri, Kansas and Minnesota. And where they go, market
expansion follows. Cities and states with the largest immigrant populations
have experienced faster economic growth and lower unemployment.
Somehow our system must address the illegal status of the three million
Mexicans who are already here and better accommodate those inevitably coming
tomorrow. A blanket amnesty, which was tried in 1986, isn't the answer since
it would only encourage more illegals and necessitate future amnesties.
Far better is to provide ways for individuals to earn legal status. For
illegals already in the country, the criteria for obtaining a permanent visa
should include demonstration of stable employment and tax compliance. Those
who don't already speak English should have to show they're trying to learn.
In addition, we need more channels for legal entry into the U.S. The two
countries share a 2,000-mile border with 43 points of entry. So long as
Mexicans believe a better life awaits them in America, they will come--legally
or illegally. We should encourage them to take the legal route by implementing
guest worker programs and increasing the quotas for temporary and permanent
visas.
All these were among the proposals being discussed by President Bush and
Mexican President Vicente Fox before September 11. They are even more
important today. The aim is to ensure that immigrants are properly processed
by border officials. Their identities could be confirmed, and we would know
who was entering the country and why.
Giving those already here an opportunity to come clean would also help
bring them out of the shadows. Right now, the incentive is to go underground
and stay there. Fewer resources spent chasing hard-working Mexicans means more
resources spent sorting through genuine terrorist threats.
Despite these benefits, the political sell stateside is difficult for Mr.
Bush. "The emotional popular reaction," says Douglas Rivlin of the National
Immigration Forum, "is that foreigners knocked down the Trade Center and
Pentagon, so foreigners are bad." It also doesn't help the President that
anti-immigration groups like the Center for Immigration Studies, and outspoken
GOP restrictionists--like Representatives Lamar Smith of Texas and Tom
Tancredo of Colorado--favor us-versus-them demagoguery.
There's another reason Mr. Bush should revive his immigration talks with
Mr. Fox, whom he's scheduled to visit later this month. The cold political
reality, as Democrats like Mr. Gephardt know, is that the Hispanic population
is America's fastest-growing ethnic group. A deal with Mr. Fox would have
symbolic importance and resonate with Latinos. A Pew Center poll last month
found that 85% of Hispanic voters support giving illegal immigrants "a path to
legal status."
Proper immigration reform in short is smart politics. But most important it
will make America safer and economically stronger.